Before you disregard me as an ex-pat in the making, please finish reading. I love this nation. I love the United States for its many achievements and for its potential. Sure it’s a dysfunctional bully with an ever-dwindling concern for self-improvement, but who among us doesn’t have at least one friend or family member like that? Who among us hasn’t been that themselves, even if just for a short time? We don’t give up, we don’t throw the baby out with the bath water. Half the world is in a drought, don’t go throwing water away at all, regardless of its baby content.
The United States has seldom, if ever, been lower than it is right now. For every six Americans, two are obese[i] and one doesn’t have enough to eat[ii] (yet we throw away over 30% of our available food supply every year[iii]). The WHO rated the U.S. as 38th[iv] for quality of healthcare worldwide, yet we pay more than anyone else (this was in 2000, but they haven’t done that kind of comprehensive rating since, as I could find). Just over 1% of our population is in prison or jail[v] and that is not a small number. Russia has only 0.6% of its population behind bars[vi]. Russia incarcerates fewer people than we do. Education? We’re way behind there, too, not even breaking the top 20 in overall education skills of 15 year olds[vii], all categories of which we performed worse in than four years prior. One hardly needs to cite statistics for income disparity in the US, but the uber-rich are the richest they’ve been since the roaring ‘20s and the poor are poorer than ever[viii]. At least our unemployment rate is improving, down from just under 10% to just over 6% in the last five years[ix]. One must never forget the good.
So people are poor and hungry and since they’re poor they can’t afford our disproportionately expensive healthcare, but they desperately need it because they aren’t eating right; it would probably be crappy even if they could. But hey, since our kids are getting progressively dumber, they probably won’t notice and it looks like they’ll still be able to be productive members of a society that decreasingly values the majority of its productive population. How’s that for a bright and shiny tomorrow?
Things need fixed, right? Not many people would argue that. If you doubt me, if you think the system works exactly as it should, I would argue that you are either in the 1% or you are a touch naïve. Offended? Go out among the people and ask them what they think. Find me 10 people who think the United States works exactly as it should and I will write you a personal letter of apology.
The popular discussions seem to focus on high order solutions, particularly those associated with the major political parties. If the Democrats can’t fix it, that must mean the Republicans can, right? Right? Right?! If that were true, we would have witnessed a different trend in the last 200 years. Personally, I am baffled by the loyalty people have to their parties after the circus that comes to town every election. The alternatives do explain that away, though, since it seems that only extremists can ever get themselves organized enough to even have a seat at the table.
We look to the government to pass laws that will save us from the corporations, save us from other parts of the government, and even save us from ourselves. We look to the government to step aside when we don’t like their solutions, so we can fix things ourselves, then we watch the worst among us make things so bad that we need the government to come back (regulation of banks over the last 40 years is a decent example of that roller coaster).
Unfortunately, it doesn’t seem that the high order solution is as simple as “big government” or “small government”. If you accept that, then please join me in saying, “Thank you, bipartisan politics. You may go now.” If you don’t accept that, let’s continue.
When you play Democrats vs. Republicans, you are playing a simple game, a game with a single strategy and a single goal. That goal is whatever your party tells you it is. Before you shoot me down, consider this: If you are loyal to a party and ever tried to argue a particular plank that you happen to agree with from the other side, how did that go? You found your fellow Democrats/Republicans to be accepting and open to moderate discussion, didn’t you? Republicans are happy to engage a reasonable and logical open border policy with Mexico. Democrats are happy to allow state-rights for determining welfare eligibility.
What do your Republican friends say about the children showing up at the Mexican border, starving and homeless (I would cite this, but there isn’t much for objective statistics on this so I leave it to you). Do they say it’s in the American spirit to turn away desperate children, or even men and women, who only want to be American? Are we so far removed from the immigration rushes of the early 20th century that we forget how almost everyone got here? Would it be easier to recycle the Statue of Liberty into a wall between us and everyone else?
How do your Democratic friends respond to the abuse of welfare funds? When they envision supporting the poorest among us, preventing any child from starving, do they see bags of Doritos and boxes of Twinkies? Do they see the national standard leaving some still starving in expensive states despite welfare plus two jobs while in cheaper states it makes more sense to take no job at all? These are statistics you can only get from the streets. Make some poor friends, if you don’t have any. If you do, please prove me wrong.
The real issue here is not picking a position right this second, it’s in how we approach issues. Thanks to the powerhouse parties, we are discouraged from addressing problems individually. This can be seen in presidential debates that invariably turn into mudslinging and party-line shouting. No question about an issue should ever be responded to by bringing up another issue. That is party tactics, not problem solving. Group thinking has created this crisis, it has pinned us up against party lines. We have to end group thinking, we have to become individuals again.
So how can individuals heal a nation, or the world for that matter? Sociologists would most likely hate me for saying this, but humanity is a sum of its parts. Every one of us makes choices every day and affects those around us every day. We are all carriers of philosophy and ideas and we all communicate our thoughts and feelings whether we mean to or not. With this in mind, it is utterly, completely, invariably essential that we as individuals pour daily effort into living out some prime virtues. While everyone has their own and everyone always will, I will now argue for those that I see as the foundation of a cure for tomorrow. Magnanimity, generosity, accountability, competence, and courage. These virtues applied on a daily and individual basis can do more good than a thousand years of bills and amendments.
Magnanimity
If there is a single human virtue that would heal our species, this is the one. I admit a personal fascination with Aristotle, though I encountered this word and its various definitions before I knew that Aristotle was so closely tied to the position of “magnanimity” in Western civilization’s hierarchy of virtues (it is the prime virtue by that definition). I encourage you to explore the different interpretations of this word as it has been lauded by one culture or another all over the world, including Confucius who predated Aristotle by about two centuries.
The history of magnanimity is interesting, but I am most concerned with its future. I would hazard that Americans are most in need of this virtue as we are, most thoroughly of all nations, poisoned with self-entitlement. Other cultures have their own vices, many share in those of the U.S., but this is where I live and this is where I see a path less traveled by, begging to be taken.
Magnanimity is humility and graciousness and dignity of the spirit rather than of the mind. This last is the most concerning trend today; people are obsessed with the respect they think they get. Because of this, we are also more interested in forcing respect than earning it. This is toxic. Whether it’s police or elected officials or professional athletes or teachers or your boss at work or even a self-entitled customer, everyone has witnessed someone who would rather coerce temporary respect through fear and force, a respect that is likely to evaporate the second you’re out of earshot, than to behave in a way worthy of respect. If we are honest with ourselves, most of us have indulged our ego and chased this kind of respect at least once. We are so terrified of being seen as weak in any light that we trample any chance of demonstrating genuine strength. In this context, magnanimity is the art of earning genuine respect while casting aside the selfish need to feel respected.
That is not to say that magnanimity is a virtue for the weak. Saadi Shirazi, a Persian poet of much renown, said, “The best loved by God are those that are rich, yet have the humility of the poor, and those that are poor and have the magnanimity of the rich.” From the farthest corner of the world, we see an ancient culture that lauds the value of casting aside self-entitlement and embracing magnanimity (one could argue that failing to abide by the principle of magnanimity is what led the Persian Empire to collapse). Closer to home and modern times, Winston Churchill said, “In war, resolution. In defeat, defiance. In victory, magnanimity. In peace, goodwill.” The mighty have no need to flaunt their might. True strength exists regardless of perception and conquest is not enhanced by self-indulgence of the conquerors.
For a nation as accustomed to victory as the United States (there is perhaps no other place in the world that fixates on its own success of any measure and ignores its failures of any scale so completely as in the U.S.), the idea of magnanimity appears completely lost in what can only be described as hypocrisy. Sports alone are sufficient evidence of this. Even if you are not a sports fan, and especially if you are, how often have you heard something like, “I don’t care if my team wins, I just want the Nieberflurbens to lose.” (If that’s a real team anywhere in any sport, let me know so I may commence immediate support of them.) We all too often want to see other people lose more often than we want to see ourselves or anyone we care about win. Reality TV is a media movement fixated on failures, both personal and competitive. Internally and externally, we prize the defeat of others and expect our own to be ignored.
Have I rubbed that point in enough, yet? I’m not sure if I have, but we can move on.
Magnanimity is a virtue that serves in all circumstances. A winner can show it by being humble and respectful rather than flaunting whatever fleeting victory they have achieved (study human history, all victory is temporary). A loser can show magnanimity by freely sharing whatever they have left and admiring the victor for their success. Human dignity runs deeper than the moment, losing cannot take it from us, no individual can take it from us. We can only give it up. And how often do we give it up when we think we are basking in glory?
To simplify, magnanimity is the practice of giving respect in all things and demanding it in none. It is giving ourselves to a community in the hopes that it will reciprocate, but not requiring it to. It is also accepting that we are not always the best, not always deserving of high honors, and sometimes we are genuinely not good enough. In a magnanimous world there is no shame in the outcome, no shame in coming in second or third or last while another wins the spotlight. The only shame in such a world comes from poor conduct.
I could go on endlessly about the permutations of magnanimity. I hope that you are inspired to do the same. Explore it, enact it, learn to see it and learn to show it. If I spend my life exploring the depth of this virtue, I expect to die with a full heart.
Generosity
As virtues go, generosity comes down pretty close to magnanimity. But I hope to convince you, as I am convinced, that it is a distinct thing, particularly in the modern United States. Magnanimity is a philosophical virtue and one that is essential to sincere generosity, but the vastness of magnanimity calls for a more specific focus in this case. While magnanimity is how we heal the hearts and minds of humanity, generosity is how we heal ourselves in a much more tangible sense.
Humankind is starving. We are homeless, we are sick, we are without water, and we are without education or opportunity. Anyone reading this most likely has not wanted for these things in any real way, but America does not represent the majority of humanity when it comes to basic needs. And even among ourselves we see these issues.
Let’s consider the U.S. for a moment and put to rest any myth that we can’t feed ourselves. In the beginning I cited some statistics, specifically that about 17% of our population suffers from “food insecurity” which roughly means that they either don’t get enough to eat or they don’t get enough quality food to eat[x]. I also mentioned that over 33% of our population is obese. Now does that mean that they eat more than they need to? Yes. Yes it does. Not to say that non-obese people don’t eat more than they need, too. That most definitely happens. Pile on the waste of 30% of our food supply every year and what you get is not a sustainability issue, it’s one of efficiency and distribution.
My math may be shaky here, so correct me if I’m wrong, but if 70% of our food feeds 83% of our population (we can disregard that it overfeeds 40% of that 83%, since we aren’t sure quite how much it overfeeds that bunch), then 84% of our total food would feed everyone, still allowing for a healthy margin of unhealthy overeating.
Now do we suppose that 30% of wasted food was being urgently rushed to those in need and just didn’t quite make it? That sure could be the case. I may have us all wrong. But is it also possible that, since nobody bought it, it was thrown away? And what’s wrong with that? We’re all capitalists here, nothing should be free.
Here’s where I lose a bunch of you. I say it should. What the hell are we even doing on this planet, as Americans, as the self-proclaimed greatest nation on earth, and as members of the planet’s most intellectually advanced residents, if we can’t even provide basic needs? I’m not saying we need to hand out ice cream and pizza to everyone who shows up with a hand out, but have we not passed the point where ANYONE on our soil should be starving?
I say we have. This is the information age, we have internet coming out of our asses (almost literally, if you keep your phone in your back pocket), we are more connected than ever and there is no earthly reason why we shouldn’t be able to figure out how to provide basic sustenance to anyone who needs it while protecting the capitalist values of being able to buy fancier stuff if you’ve got the money.
If you disagree, if you think we are better off in a world where people are driven to desperation for an absurdly basic reason, then this is not for you and I have no good to offer you. If you agree that a world where those with the power help those without, where the basic level of existence is raised across all of humanity, then you may just have a generous soul.
Remember we are not having a bipartisan conversation. There are no party politics distracting from an actual solution, in our imaginary little world where this is being written by me and read by you. We can have a calm, reasoned conversation where I say something like “put a roof over everyone’s head” and someone else doesn’t immediately shout about me wanting to take your hard-earned home and give it away to someone without a job. Is that really the only possible result of trying to ensure nobody has to die of exposure if they don’t want to? Of course not, it’s just easier to give up on the issue than hash out the messy, complicated, and, yes, expensive solution that would better our species as a whole.
This is perhaps the most important distinction between generosity and magnanimity. Magnanimity costs us nothing but our hubris. Generosity actually costs us. We actually do have to give of ourselves for the sake of someone else. We may not be able to upgrade our 16 year old’s car this year, we may not be able to go to Cabo this winter, we may not even be able to eat out this weekend like we usually do. This virtue, more than any other, comes within a razor’s edge of hurting us. That which we have earned is given to those who have not earned it. Not all of it, not even half of it. You earned it; that counts for a lot. Again, still a capitalist here. But sharing our extra goes a long way toward ensuring someone else gets just enough.
So maybe I’ve lost you, but if I have and you’re reading on anyway, I appreciate it. Placing this virtue second is possibly a poor choice, it is surely the hardest sell. But if anyone thinks that correcting the trajectory of our humanity is easy, they should probably be writing their own version of this so I can try that way instead.
Generosity is hard. It is costly. Sharing what we have will always make us wonder if it really needs to be us this time, maybe it’s someone else’s turn. It will make us miss what we could have given ourselves instead. But I swear to you, it will heal our species’ soul.
Accountability
Let’s roll the intensity back a bit. Accountability is a virtue that everyone can get behind, especially when it’s applied to everyone else. Of all the virtues I listed, this is the most in need of tempering, as well. Luckily, I’ve already talked about magnanimity so we don’t have to go over all that again.
Trust is all well and good, hopefully we are all worthy of it and hopefully we are wise in giving it. But humans will never be perfect, we’ll always slip from time to time and we’ll always drift away from the goal now and then. That’s where community comes in. Near and far, village and corporation, family and citizens, we all owe honesty to each other and we are all accountable.
So why didn’t I put “honesty” here and cut out the middle man? I believe accountability gets us more than just honesty. Honesty is integral to a functional, accountable society or everyone would always get caught doing wrong. That’s built in. Accountability goes a step further by keeping us in each other’s lives. A senator can be honest to the bone, but without a connection to the people, that honesty achieves nothing. An accountable senator has to interact, has to be close to the needs and concerns of the voters. This is my favorite example of tying the individual to the system.
While it is popular to lay all the burdens of the government at the feet of the president and while I have a rant about that three times longer than what I’ve written here so far, I’m going to breeze through that to my point. Basically, consider the way official action happens in this country, and please join me in realizing that the Congress is responsible for almost every decision made ever. Not only do they have the power to do things, they have the much grander and less observable power to not do things. A president is free to do and not do things as well, but apart from appointing Cabinet members, members of SCOTUS, the veto, and executive orders, all of which tend to be very visible, they don’t do a lot of actual decision making. Even when they are personally involved outside those areas, they are again subject to intense public scrutiny. For the most part, they are acting out (“executing” if you will) the decisions of Congress, the ones who have the true potential to be shifty.
Congress is a mass of individuals, not even a particularly large mass. They in turn represent smaller units of individuals, all of which have a direct vote in that appointment. Sure, Senators and Representatives come from entire states and some of those have a lot of voters to account for. But if Gangnam Style can be seen over two billion times in two years, don’t tell me the internet can’t be used to organize mere millions with two years between elections. The voter is the individual that matters and the voters have the power to take away the much more significant vote enjoyed by those with Congressional seats.
To bring it full circle, if we want accountability, we have to enforce it. If your Senator isn’t accountable, remove him. No Senator or Representative can re-enter office if they are not voted there. If a business refuses to be held accountable, do not give them your money. No business dominates the market without consumers giving it the approval of their patronage. More than any other virtue I will discuss, accountability is about enforcement. That’s why it is more than honesty, it is the virtue of embracing honesty no matter how rigorous the examination. A magnanimous person who believes in accountability would never begrudge a hard question or have anything to hide from the questioner. This virtue, esteemed by all and demanded by all, is best suited to curing the ills of our systems, if we can bring ourselves to chase it.
Competence
If any virtue is obvious, it should be this one. I list it here because I do not see it being as obvious as it should be in our culture. We live in an amazing time for communication. The human race has quite literally never been more connected than it is now and that comes as a burden as well as a benefit. With freely available information, we also have a responsibility to recognize and share real information as opposed to whatever biased, half-valid, or entirely fictional stories are too often shared on our social media.
If you use the internet, I venture that you would agree when I say sensationalist interpretations of otherwise mundane and usually limited facts are running rampant. Real science gets buried and contradicted and confused by faulty analysis and premature conclusions while absolute bullshit stories capitalizing on whatever fear is most prevalent at the moment get passed around under the barely acknowledged guise of “satire”. An “independent news source” as often as not means a completely non-news source that exists purely to draw clicks from unsuspecting news seekers. Television is not much better with celebrity doctors, some of which do at least have degrees vaguely related to what they’re talking about, who spend their allotted time between commercials pitching what amounts to modern day snake oils, changing their product of choice as the slower and more rigorous reports of actual science lumber along behind, waiting for their pesky facts.
Since the advent of internet news, good old newspapers with their fact checking and attempts at objective analysis have never looked so good. The one lesson the internet has taught us should be that being right is better than being fast, every time. Yet major news sources still get caught basing their reports on Tweets and Facebook statuses.
Accountability is certainly a factor here, but in order to hold anyone accountable, we must first pursue competence in ourselves. We have to slow down and learn to be rigorous. We have to learn what a logical conclusion is versus a correlation or unrelated bit of sensationalism. Check facts, look for facts that should be present but are omitted. Look out for conclusions that arrive spontaneously and magically support something inflammatory. Be prepared to admit that your own perspective may be faulty. Nobody is right all the time which means we all have the potential to be wrong at any time. The only way you can be sure of yourself or anyone else is to be rigorous in pursuing competence.
Courage
As a closing bookend to my list, courage is perhaps most similar to magnanimity in that it is abstract, internal, and fundamental to a better tomorrow. It would perhaps be better placed within magnanimity, but I believe it is worthy of its own place because it plays a part in all that we do and think. It is impossible to be magnanimous without the courage to risk our dignity; it is impossible to be generous without the courage to risk our material security; it is impossible to demand, and thus offer yourself up to, accountability without the courage to lay yourself bare before scrutiny; and it is impossible to value competence without the courage to admit we ourselves have more to learn. Perhaps more than anything, it is impossible to participate in change without the courage to stand alone, to risk hatred, to never meet success.
Courage is the only way to break the status quo. It is the only chance we have to write a better future than we currently see laid in front of us. Will I have the courage to support my ideas when someone smarter or better liked or more successful than me is laughing me off or telling me I’m wrong? I don’t know. That’s why we have to think about courage every minute of the day, every time we face a moment and bring a virtue to bear against it. We have to store it up and prepare for it to be tested.
Conclusion
Even as I read back through this I can think of a handful of other things I could have included, but even in retrospect I think less is more. I can’t even pretend to dictate every detail of how people should think or act and I struggle enough to live out these virtues when the opportunity arises. But I do believe sincerely what I’ve written here. Life is messy and humanity is complicated, but it would be regressive of us to pretend we are each on our own. As a species we have a long history of doing wrong to one another and as a nation we are pretty much just a microcosm of the species. That is all in the past. The best we can do for ourselves and those who come after us is to surpass everything that has come before. Maybe these virtues aren’t the way to do that, but I think they are and a conversation that proves otherwise is better than no conversation at all. A chance to be better is better than no chance at all.
“The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.”
-Edmund Burke
References
[i] http://www.cdc.gov/obesity/data/adult.html
[ii] http://www.ers.usda.gov/topics/food-nutrition-assistance/food-security-in-the-us/key-statistics-graphics.aspx#.U_UXnfldWoo
[iii] http://www.ers.usda.gov/publications/eib-economic-information-bulletin/eib121.aspx?mkt_tok=3RkMMJWWfF9wsRonuKjOZKXonjHpfsX56%2BwqXaC%2FlMI%2F0ER3fOvrPUfGjI4ATsthI%2BSLDwEYGJlv6SgFT7DGMaNny7gNUxI%3D#.U_UWm_ldWor
[iv] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WHO%27s_ranking_of_health_care_systems
[v] http://www.nytimes.com/2008/02/28/us/28cnd-prison.html
[vi] http://www.nytimes.com/2008/04/23/world/americas/23iht-23prison.12253738.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0
[vii] http://www.northcountrypublicradio.org/news/npr/248329823/u-s-high-school-students-slide-in-math-reading-science
[viii] http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2013/12/05/u-s-income-inequality-on-rise-for-decades-is-now-highest-since-1928/
[ix] http://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS14000000
[x] http://www.ers.usda.gov/topics/food-nutrition-assistance/food-security-in-the-us/definitions-of-food-security.aspx#.U_fhgfldWoo



